What happened to my hilarious self-confidence?
And so, dear readers, I was cleaning out my backpacks today. And yes I mean backpacks. Plural. I still have not emptied my backpack from senior year. While I was going through it I found my Provo writing assessment. I read it and it is hilarious so this post is my paper. Read it and come to realize how funny I am and how dumb teachers are for giving me full points on it. I very obviously prove myself wrong multiple times in it. Perhaps they felt bad about my made-up 10th grade love.
-Can you keep a secret?
-Yes.
-Well, so can I.
Never has such a statement been so hurtful. Is secrecy a good thing? Should others expect us to keep their secrets? What deep psychological and physiological effects does secret-keeping have? I will answer these questions and more. Firstly, no. Secondly, no. Thirdly, secrets have a profound affect on personal well-being; just look at Raskolnikov in Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment.
There are so many instances when telling others secrets are helpful. The woman who is being abused, the man who is two-timing his girlfriends, the child who wets the bed. All three have a secret. All three would be better off telling the truth. The woman could stop being bothered. The girls could dump the man to leave him to a life of pathetic bachelorhood. The child could be teased by his/her peers until they decide on a good medication or rubber sheets. The man looking at child porn on the library computer could be a budding sex offender and your tattling has just gotten him safely locked away. It may shatter personal lives but they were sacrificed for the common good.
There are many ethical questions behind secret keeping. Is it going against federal privacy laws to share secrets? Is it injurious to lead a smear campaign in politics? No. The fan magazines are bursting with the "secret" lives of celebrities. Are they getting sued? Well, yes. But who is coming out on top? They get publicity! They sprung the story first! It is their right to reap the fruits of their labors. They get financial backing for the secrets they spill. That can't be a bad thing. What is the harm of a TV voiceover yelling, "He lied to us! He DID go to Woodstock!" While negative pictures of condidates roll? So polls in his favor may go down a little bit. Nothing so monumental as to lose an election over a little bit of fun in the sixties will happen. Who DIDN'T have fun in the sixties? It was a blast! The voters have a right to know if their elected officials have run around a muddy field in the nude. It makes them more approachable.
Now consider the ghastly effects of secret-keeping. Rodya, in Crime and Punishment had just killed an evil pawnbroker and her sister. He did a good deed for humanity. He tells no one of his deed and begins to go crazy. He blabs on about a bloody sock, he dreams about bloody, dripping axes, he passes out multiple times. When he confesses and is put to work in Siberia he is truly happy. By spilling his secret he opens up the door to the possibility of love in his life. That is fantastic! Now, if he doesn't die in hard labor, he can live with his love--all thanks to giving up his secret. Another example of this is in Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen. Mr. Wickam is a horrible womanizer and gold-digger. Elizabeth knows this and yet, does not want to injure Mr. Darcy through a series of long-winded and complicated events, and so does not reveal the truth. Because she kept this secret her stupid and frivolous sister, Lydia, eloped with Wickham and cost Mr. Darcy dearly. And so, she injured him anyway. Fabulous.
Finally, a personal example. In 10th grade I was in love. I thought the boy loved me too. I was wrong. Through a sad twist of fate I discovered he was cheating on me. He scammed on everything and anything in a skirt. It was a very painful time for me. If only I had known the truth I would not have dated him.
Secret-keeping is hurtful and wrong. At the very least, by sharing secrets, entertainment is a guarantee. Remember what our dear friend Mr. Bennett says, "What do we live for but to make sport for our neighbors and laugh at them in our turn?"
I hope you enjoyed this waltz down memory lane. I certainly did.


14 Comments:
you got an A for this? Who was your teacher? Not that its bad, its great for blog world, but for school? my favorite part is when you just write "fabulous" as a whole sentence. so good.
yes. It is pretty awesome. It wasn't just one teacher. It went through two teachers who both gave me perfect scores. Man alive. Maybe they just didn't read it.
yeah, pretty much those writing assesments were amazing. It obviously depended on who got your paper. I wrote a wonderful paper one year and got crap scores, the next year was complete and utter crap (and not even in a funny way) and it got full points. schooling systems. fabulous.
yes. It is quite nice. I wrote that one in about 15 minutes. I could not believe it. That was almost as good as when I got full points on my hero essay. My thesis was that this guy was a hero because he was a sexy beast. Cha-ching.
sexy beast? I love the phrase, but for a paper...are you sure you weren't in the special ed. class?
Maybe she has the cancer, and the teachers felt bad. I feel kind of bad for writing that.
you are a horrible girl. but you are right. i did come down with a case of the cancer. i can't believe we actually said that in the movie.
yeah, I think that ruined it. of course i'm joking. it was the fact that i wasn't in it.
AGREED!
I thought it was tasteful.
But my farts are not. That is another story.
good point. well made.
I wouldn't want to taste them. And that's that.
I'm officially quite disgusted by the tasting comment. So much so that I have forgotten what I was going to comment about. Oh well.
Post a Comment
<< Home